As you can tell by my “Pros and Cons” I would pick breathable waders over neoprene in most cases. The only time I would consider neoprene is if I did most of my hunting in very cold weather or water. Even then I would be tempted to stick with breathable waders. If you buy your breathable waders a little loose, you can layer socks, base layers, and sweaters and jackets underneath them.
Warm vs Cold Climate
The only time I would choose Neoprene over breathable would be for really cold weather or climates. You can get Neoprene in thicknesses of 3.5mm or 5mm, depending on how warm you need to be. In warmer climates where you might only see a handful of hunts in near-freezing weather, breathable would be my choice.
Insulation in the Boots
Many waders come with extra insulation in the boots, often in a product called Thinsulate™. This is an area where, again, you might consider your climate. A higher number of Thinsulate™ means the boots have more insulation in them, making them warmer. My old neoprene waders came with 1,000-gram insulated boots, while the breathable ones had 600-gram insulated boots. With the right kind of wool socks, I can say in my area the difference has not been all that noticeable.
Choose your waders first on how the boots fit. Then pay attention to the rest of the fit. If you’re a larger guy, then you can choose “stout” waders. Neoprene is designed to fit tighter and gets really bulky when loose. I can even hinder your movement if you don’t get the fit right. I chose a looser fit for the breathable waders because it’s easier to layer clothing underneath them.
SEAMS TEARING ON MY NEOPRENE WADERS.
Over time, the seams on waders will give you the most trouble with leaking, resulting in drips that make their way into your boots. My cheaper neoprene waders’ seals are not joined particularly well and the stitching pulls apart. This causes the welded seals on the inside to weep or drip. My breathable waders, on the other hand, have better seals with more tape and sealant. After two seasons, they, too, are starting to weep and will require repairs. Try to find a pair within your budget that has better than average welded, taped and otherwise sealed seams.
Care and Storage
After each hunt, it’s good to dry the inside of the waders to keep them from smelling bad. I use a simple boot dryer with extensions for this. Store your waders indoors to prevent them from getting too hot or dry. For neoprene, I hang them upside down by the boots up to minimize strain on the seams. These keep them from folding and drying out too much would result in weak points in the neoprene that would crack or tear. My breathable waders, which are a Cabela’s brand, can be dried then stored folded in a large tub.
There are many products and ways to repair waders, but I think I’ve found a way to patch both neoprene and breathable with something that works.
Basic neoprene waders can cost $100 or less but don’t expect these to last much longer than a season or two without extensive repairs. Breathable waders can cost nearly twice as much and mine made it through a couple of seasons before I had to seal the seams again.